This is my daughter Silence reading to her young friend Elia over the weekend:
Silence: “Well, I don’t like to brag, but I’m telling you, Liz,
That speaking of cooks, I’m the best that there is!”
Elia: Who’s Liz?
Silence: Liz is his little sister.
Elia: Why does he have a little sister?
Silence: He just does.
Elia: Why’s her name Liz?
Silence: Because it rhymes with “is.”
Elia: Why does it have to rhyme?
I couldn’t help picturing Elia twenty years in the future, as some editorial phenom at Random House:
This seems a rather traditional family, and Liz is a standard English name. Strive for more diversity in the text? Also, rhyme seems somewhat forced. Would a small boy really say, ‘I’m the best that there is’? Consider rewriting without the rhyme…
Dr. Seuss is lucky he didn’t live in the age of Elia.
Ha! Go, Elia!
What do you think, Tanya? Was this you at age 3?